Knowing that you would repeat this life might conjure up an urgency to add value and meaning to your existence. Perhaps you would be kinder to others, live with greater intentionality, and search for your defining purpose. The Stoics believed in a cyclical view of the universe, and adopted a worldview that was void of "destructive emotions". They believed that the best possible life is one without unnecessary extremes that result from poor judgements. It seems like a good goal to strive for, right? Remain collected, calm, and try your best not to let yourself be pushed or pulled to the extremes.
Now imagine if everyone tried to live their life without extreme emotions, on either end of the spectrum. Imagine a world where no one ever became infuriated, or uncontrollably passionate. Imagine if everyone was completely in control of their emotions at all time.
Perhaps I'm of the minority when I claim that a human with complete control of his emotions is seriously lacking in humanness. One of my favorite things about being human is letting go sometimes and letting my emotions take over. Think of Nicolas Cage in "The Family Man". He's forced to live thirteen years of his life over, (though he is aware of the repeat) and in so is forced to choose between two separate paths that his life can take. One is full of riches, fame, success, beautiful women, and luxury. The other is filled with stress, money issues, and solitude. Cage's character chooses the latter, even knowing that his life will have less of an impact on the world than it otherwise would have.
So why did he make that choice? I think it's because he found value in the interactions between himself and those around him. As a car salesman, he won't live a life filled of value and meaning, but he will have a tremendous impact on a select few, namely his wife and children. He won't live as calm and collected a life, but he will experience true human emotions, like love and despair.
Here comes my big conclusion. Thanks for reading this far....
By posing questions about the implications of an infinitely repeated life, Nietzsche is doing something terrible. He's encouraging people to live by what they know to be meaningful and good. But the truth is, I don't know what's definitively meaningful and good. I'm still figuring it out, and I hope to still be figuring it out a minute before I die. I like to take risks! I like to change myself without knowing whether the outcome will be for the better or the worse. If I knew I had to relive this life, I would be less inclined to take risks, and I'd be in a bigger rush to figure out who I am, to find my defining purpose. I prefer to take my time, to figure it out as I go along, and to trip a few times along the way.
Now imagine if everyone tried to live their life without extreme emotions, on either end of the spectrum. Imagine a world where no one ever became infuriated, or uncontrollably passionate. Imagine if everyone was completely in control of their emotions at all time.
Perhaps I'm of the minority when I claim that a human with complete control of his emotions is seriously lacking in humanness. One of my favorite things about being human is letting go sometimes and letting my emotions take over. Think of Nicolas Cage in "The Family Man". He's forced to live thirteen years of his life over, (though he is aware of the repeat) and in so is forced to choose between two separate paths that his life can take. One is full of riches, fame, success, beautiful women, and luxury. The other is filled with stress, money issues, and solitude. Cage's character chooses the latter, even knowing that his life will have less of an impact on the world than it otherwise would have.
So why did he make that choice? I think it's because he found value in the interactions between himself and those around him. As a car salesman, he won't live a life filled of value and meaning, but he will have a tremendous impact on a select few, namely his wife and children. He won't live as calm and collected a life, but he will experience true human emotions, like love and despair.
Here comes my big conclusion. Thanks for reading this far....
By posing questions about the implications of an infinitely repeated life, Nietzsche is doing something terrible. He's encouraging people to live by what they know to be meaningful and good. But the truth is, I don't know what's definitively meaningful and good. I'm still figuring it out, and I hope to still be figuring it out a minute before I die. I like to take risks! I like to change myself without knowing whether the outcome will be for the better or the worse. If I knew I had to relive this life, I would be less inclined to take risks, and I'd be in a bigger rush to figure out who I am, to find my defining purpose. I prefer to take my time, to figure it out as I go along, and to trip a few times along the way.
No comments:
Post a Comment